Italy’s Chamber Moves to Pass Antisemitism Law Using IHRA Definition
Italy's Chamber of Deputies is expected to give final approval to the antisemitism bill. How each party votes and why the IHRA definition divides them.

Italy’s Camera dei Deputati (the lower house of Parliament) was expected to give final approval to a bill against antisemitism by the evening, according to ANSA. The Senate has already passed the text, so a yes vote in the Chamber makes it law without further changes.
The most disputed part of the bill writes into Italian law the working definition of antisemitism adopted by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), together with the indicators needed to apply it. Opponents say this could blur the line between antisemitic prejudice and political criticism of Israel’s government.
What the bill says
The text states that the Republic rejects every form of antisemitism, supports action against it and works to stop antisemitic prejudice from spreading in Italy. It also says that freedom of political criticism, freedom of expression and the rights of assembly and association remain protected under the Constitution.
The IHRA definition it adopts was drawn up in Bucharest on May 26, 2016, AGI reported. The bill grew out of a proposal that Graziano Delrio of the Partito Democratico (PD, the main center-left party) filed in the Senate in a personal capacity about a year ago, later merged with other proposals.
How the parties are expected to vote
According to AGI, the bill should pass with votes from Fratelli d’Italia, Lega, Forza Italia and Noi Moderati, the parties of the governing center-right, plus two opposition groups, Azione and Italia Viva. The same coalition approved it in the Senate.
The Movimento 5 Stelle and Alleanza Verdi e Sinistra (AVS) are voting against. So is Futuro Nazionale: Rossano Sasso, speaking for the party, said the bill risks creating a new crime of opinion that would limit the free speech protected by Article 21 of the Constitution.
The PD is split. In the Senate it abstained, while six of its reformist senators voted in favor. After an internal meeting with party leader Elly Schlein in recent weeks, the party line moved to a no vote. ANSA reported that almost all of the PD’s 68 deputies would vote against, with Lorenzo Guerini, Lia Quartapelle, Piero Fassino and possibly Virginio Merola expected to abstain or, more likely, vote yes.
In the Chamber committee, the majority and Italia Viva voted in favor, M5S, AVS and Futuro Nazionale voted against, +Europa abstained and the PD did not take part, ANSA said.
The fight over criticism of Israel
Angelo Bonelli of AVS called the text a “legge bavaglio” (gag law) meant to shield the Netanyahu government. Senator Maurizio Gasparri of Forza Italia answered that the law protects no government and targets racial and antisemitic discrimination, and said Bonelli could not have read it.
At the end of September, Liliana Segre asked the parties to accept a small change stating that criticism of Israel, as of any other country, is not automatically antisemitic, in the hope of a unanimous vote. The Chamber committee did not reach that compromise. Center-right sources told ANSA there is no room for amendments, since any change would shrink the bill’s support.
Two appeals reached the center-left on the eve of the vote. Emanuele Fiano, president of Sinistra per Israele, said the law creates no new penalties or crimes and does not limit the right to criticize Israeli governments. The association Libertà Eguale said the opposition had no reason to vote against the text.
The day before, the center-right majority rejected a proposal from the PD, M5S and AVS to ban imports from Israeli settlements in the West Bank.
What it means for people in Italy
Once the Chamber approves it, the IHRA definition becomes a reference point in Italian law for identifying antisemitism. Supporters, including Fiano, say it adds no new offenses. Critics in M5S, AVS, Futuro Nazionale and most of the PD say it could be used against speech critical of Israel’s policies. How courts and public bodies apply the definition will show which reading holds.



